IS WOKERY STULTIFYING ART?
I am a writer. I write fiction and non-fiction. Very few
people have ever heard of me. I used to
think that was a bad thing. Now I’m not
so sure. At least, because I am relatively unknown, I do not have to suffer the
malignant intensity of the wokerati minutely examining my every dot and comma
for transgression against their unforgiving ideology.
For the past year or so, I have found myself constantly
chagrined by the extent to which the tyranny of political correctness is
infiltrating every stratum of society - universities, schools, the theatre, the
cinema, journalism, sports, literature. Nothing and no one is safe from their
fanatical scrutiny. The irony is that the woke brigade scream stridently their
aim in life is to ensure equality of opportunity and freedom of expression for
all groups in society, yet it has become increasingly clear that this equality
is only for those who agree one hundred percent with their views. Those who
disagree are castigated, hounded and ultimately cancelled. JK Rowling, after
reading an article which was sprinkled with numerous repetitions of the awkward
and inelegant phrase, ‘people who menstruate’, had the temerity to tweet that
she recalled the use of a simpler, much more precise word to describe this
societal grouping – women. Howls of outrage, even death threats, followed that
perfectly sensible comment. She was, of
course ‘cancelled’, even by those three mindless ingrates, Daniel Radcliffe,
Rupert Grint and Emma Watson, who made millions on the back of Rowling’s talent.
I recently had my own, very minor, skirmish with a ‘woke’
reviewer. My most recent novel deals with human trafficking and a key character
is an evil gang-lord who happens to have come from China. One of the detectives
investigating this personage referred to him during a conversation as, ‘the
Chinaman.’ This was in dialogue, I point out again, not part of my narration. I
have always been of the opinion that the truth of dialogue in real life is that
it is intrinsically careless. Should characters in a story operate by different
rules? Apparently they should, says this reviewer. I was vociferously berated
for my inherent racism and was awarded one star for my book. The reviewer went
on to point out that I got ‘one star’ only because there was no facility to award
‘no stars’. (In the interest of balance, I should note that of the hundred plus
reviews for this book from countries as far apart as the USA, India, Canada, Australia,
New Zealand and the UK, almost 80% are five stars. Just sayin’.)
The rot is everywhere. Almost every aspect of art must now
be seen through the prisms of gender diversity, white privilege, left-leaning
ideology ... etc., etc., etc. One of Hollywood’s most cherished traditions is
the knockabout think tank where a group of writers will sit in a room tossing
out all sorts of wild and idiotic ideas. It is banter, it is fun, but it is
also serious and invariably some great ideas come from it. Now I read of one
writer who says, “I sit there now and am afraid to open my mouth. These
brainstorms have become potential death-traps for the politically incorrect
where loose talk can cost careers.” Shades of 1984! The thought police are
everywhere and they are determined to reshape society into their own image and
likeness.
Even the great classics of literature are under attack at
schools and at universities. The most glaring example I have come across is the
‘cancelling’ of To Kill a Mockingbird because of its institutional racism. Good
heavens! When we studied this wonderful book during my schooldays, my entire class
were made fully aware that the book’s central message was about the evil
injustices of racism. But logic seems to hold no sway with the wokerati. Even university lecturers are writing ridiculous
triggers about Shakespeare and other great classics. Students about to read
Kidnapped, for example, are warned that the book may contain ‘episodes of
abduction’. I despair!
So, what now for writers? When we write, must we forever
write with one eye on equality and diversity? Must our characters be fully
representative of different races, the LGBTQIA spectrum, and the extreme views
of the Left? Must our dialogues be whitewashed of all human foible and become
bland vehicles for political correctness? Many movies and series on TV have
become so woke-conscious, so inclusive, pushing so many agendas, that they have
become unwatchable. Are novels to head
that way, too?
I think I'll just go on doing what I'm doing and risk the wrath of the woke.